Monday, October 20, 2008

While We Are Here.....

I have really loved the discussion on Prop. 8. I thank you all for not being hateful and minding your manners. Healthy debate is always fun. I decided while we were here on the topic of politics I would fuel the fire with one more prop.....Proposition 4. I am URGING you all to also vote NO on Prop. 4!

Proposition 4 would prohibit abortion for an unemancipated minor until 48 hours after physician notifies minor's parent, legal guardian, or, in limited cases, substitute adult relative.

I am against this no matter what because while I would like to think that all children to go to their parents about something like this I know it isn't true. What I also didn't know is that their is a lot of misunderstanding about this Prop. Thanks to my friend Kimberly, who attending a talk on Prop. 4, I understand a bit more. I copied what Kim wrote because she said it all so well.

I learned that I misunderstood parental notification at a Prop. 4 talk about two weeks ago. I was against the proposition before, fully understanding that while I hope and expect Clover would come to me if she found herself pregnant before she wanted to be, there are many girls who don't live in a supportive environment. I remember an article I read a few years ago written by a doctor offering a glimpse into her residency that featured a young teen girl impregnated by her father. The girl was begging for an abortion, saying she'd been raped by her father for years, but her mother refused to allow the abortion, saying she'd raise the child instead. The parties agreed that the mother knew of the molestation, but did nothing to stop it. Thinking about this situation makes me sick, even more so when I think that it's not an anomaly.

Before the talk, I thought parental notification was akin to getting out of gym class: a forged note not closely examined would do the trick. I was so naive. For someone under 18 to have an abortion, two letters (one sent certified mail, the other first class) go to the girl's parents or guardian notifying them that their daughter has sought an abortion, giving the parents/guardian at least 48 hours notice. It does not matter if the teen is accompanied by a family member, for instance her grandmother, which, according to Planned Parenthood, is common. For the pregnant teen to obtain a waiver, she must fill out a state form claiming her parents have abused her and/or go to juvenile court. She must incriminate her parents to obtain a waiver. Maybe her parents did nothing wrong other than having high expectations. They may not have sexually abused her, but they may expect that she excel in school and go off to a top university. Becoming pregnant wouldn't merely be a set back, but a crushing change to family relations.

A representative from Planned Parenthood told us about her job in the conservative Central Valley and about a test where she took a teenage Latina to try to get Plan B (which is NOT RU 486, as much as the anti-choice people try to link them. Plan B suppresses ovulation, just like the pill.). It took going to several pharmacies in different towns (including the small farming town where my cousins live) through the course of a day in order to get it, despite having a valid prescription and a knowledge of her rights. It wasn't that the pharmacy did not have the medicine, it's that they were unwilling to dispense it to her. Not many teens have the time and resources to get around to that many pharmacies in order to get a pill that is needed in a very timely fashion to prevent a pregnancy - and also prevent an abortion. Normally I am pretty smug about living in forward-thinking California, but then I hear stories that make me think this is another state or country all together.

One last thing the representative said that was really helpful to me as a parent of young children was a reminder not to flip out over the small things. She said if parents yell and get upset about little things like spilled juice, that child is not going to want to go to the parent when something big and bad goes wrong for fear of the response. I'll admit that I tend to flip out over small stuff - being late for school, playing with water when the kids are supposed to be brushing their teeth, crayons on the wall...I could go on forever - so I took her advice and said to Clover, "If there is anything you ever need to tell me, but are afraid to, just say 'mommy, I have something to tell you and I don't want you to get upset,' and I promise to listen and not yell and I'll try my best not to be upset." Clover looked at me like I was crazy. Later that night she came into my room and said "mommy, I have something to tell you and I don't want you to get upset." I sat down, bracing myself for horrible news. "Okay." She held out a stick of overlapping Legos and said "I made a Lego cigar!" My shoulders dropped with relief. But then, she's five, the bigger tests are yet to come.

I am begging you to think hard before you vote on this Prop. Think of your grandchildren or even your own children. We would all like to think that they would come to us about such a BIG issue but they might not feel like they could. Let's not make this HUGE decision any tougher than it already is!!!

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Oh sure take my post after you and Robyn bailed out on me at the HP party, probably headed for more exciting things. I feel like someone else who always gets left behind. :p

I missed your twitter, I only saw it when I went to your twitter page to try to track down Robyn's twitter name. If only I'd read her latest post first.

Anyway, this was a brilliant post. See you at LeapFrog.

YF said...

well, i am also on board w/ you on this too. no doubt in my mind.

Christina said...

Just like your last post, I totally agree with you. I only wish I lived in California to help you all out with my votes.

(Oh, and vote yes for California Prop. 2 also! It's a step forward in guaranteeing more humane treatment for farm animals. Since California has a lot of the meat and dairy that is sold nationwide, it affects me, too!)